At the Crossroads of American
Photography: Callahan, Siskind, Sommer
January 31 - May 13, 2009
Object labels for the exhibition
- Lynne Harrison (American,
born 1938)
- Portrait of Harry Callahan,
1966
- Collection of the Center for Creative Photography, The
University of Arizona, Tucson, Gift of the artist, 77.048.003. ©
Lynne Harrison
-
- Harry Callahan (1912-1999) was born in Detroit. In 1934,
he married Eleanor Knapp, who became his frequent model.
Callahan began photographing in 1938 and joined the Chrysler Camera Club,
where he met Ansel Adams and Arthur Siegel. Callahan credited Adams with
teaching him both the spiritual and technical vocabulary of photography
and inspiring him to make contact prints with a large-format camera.
In 1944, Callahan began working in the Chrysler darkroom printing publicity
and product images. In 1946, László Moholy-Nagy asked
him to come to Chicago to teach photography at the Institute
of Design, originally founded as the New Bauhaus. In 1948, The Museum
of Modern Art in New York presented two photography exhibitions that included
prints by Callahan, Aaron Siskind and Frederick Sommer. In
that same year, Callahan met Siskind. They cemented their friendship
during the summer of 1951 when both taught at the experimental Black Mountain
College alongside painters Robert Motherwell and Franz Kline; conceptual
composer John Cage; and choreographer Merce Cunningham. The young
artists Robert Rauschenberg and Cy Twombly were students. In 194760,
portraits of Eleanor featured prominently in Callahan's work, sometimes
joined by their daughter, Barbara, following her birth in 1950. When
Callahan and his family spent sabbaticals abroad, Sommer would replace
him as a visiting professor. In 1961, Callahan left the Institute of Design
to become the head of the photography department at the Rhode Island School
of Design in Providence, where he taught until his retirement. In 1975,
his archive, along with those of Siskind and Sommer, was one of the five
founding archives for the Center for Creative Photography, The University
of Arizona, Tucson.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Portrait of Aaron Siskind,
1951
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri. Gift of Hallmark Cards Inc., 2005.27.832
-
- Aaron Siskind (1903-1991) was born in New York and attended
The City College of New York with friends Barnett Newman and Adolph
Gottlieb, future Abstract Expressionist painters. Siskind's early fascination
with Socialist ideals led him to document the slums of New York, photographing
with the Workers Film and Photo League while making a living teaching high-school
English. He became the only photographer to join the inner circle of the
Abstract Expressionists, including Mark Rothko, Franz Kline,
Robert Motherwell and Ad Reinhardt. In 1948, encouraged by his New York
dealer, Siskind set off on a road trip that would introduce him
to Harry Callahan in Chicago. Siskind and Callahan went on a photographic
expedition to a disused car lot, exploring their common interests and becoming
immediate friends. In 1949, Siskind met Sommer in Prescott and the two
spent three months photographing together in Arizona before Siskind
returned to New York. In 1951, Siskind was the only photographer included
in The Ninth Street Art Exhibition organized by Leo Castelli, which
featured prominent artists such as Jackson Pollock and Willem de Kooning.
Also in 1951, Siskind accepted Callahan's invitation to teach photography
at Chicago's Institute of Design. There, Siskind organized an exhibition
of Frederick Sommer's work and brought Sommer in to replace Callahan
during his sabbaticals. Funded by numerous grants, Siskind traveled
to Mexico, Peru, Greece and Italy to photograph. In 1971, he followed
Callahan to Providence to teach at the Rhode Island School of Design.
Siskind was a founding member of both the Society for Photographic Education
and the Visual Studies Workshop, an experimental graduate photography program
in Rochester, New York.
-
-
- Edward Weston (American,
1886 - 1958)
- Untitled, no. 9 [portrait
of Frederick Sommer], 1944
- Collection of Naomi F. Lyons, Prescott, Arizona. ©1981
Arizona Board of Regents
-
- Frederick Sommer (1905-1999), was born in Angri, Italy,
raised and rigorously educated in Brazil, studying architecture and landscape
architecture. He was proficient in German, Italian, Portuguese and English.
After marrying Frances Elisabeth Watson, whom he met while completing his
M.A. at Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, Sommer contracted tuberculosis.
The couple traveled to Europe for his recuperation. While abroad,
Sommer began experimenting with photography. In Paris, he saw modernist,
Futurist and Cubist exhibitions. Following this trip, in 1931 the Sommers
came to Arizona for the climate and settled in Prescott in 1935. After
meeting the famed photographer Edward Weston in 1936, Sommer acquired an
8 x10-inch and was included in a number of East and West Coast museum exhibitions.
In 1949, Sommer was visited by Siskind. They immediately become
fast friends, sharing their interest in classical music, musical scores,
poetry and photography. Sommer taught Siskind games he extrapolated from
Surrealism, and the two photographed together in nearby ghost towns. At
Siskind's suggestion, Sommer replaced Callahan at the Institute of Design
during his sabbatical leave in 195758 and Siskind in 1963; and replaced
Callahan again at the Rhode Island School of Design in 1973.
Sommer taught briefly at Prescott College during the late 1960s. He
and Frances traveled abroad and sojourned in Japan in 1969. In 1974, Sommer
received a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Fellowship-an honor extended
to Callahan and Siskind as well.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Weed against Sky, Detroit,
1948
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Callahan met Ansel Adams in 1941 at a workshop and was
deeply influenced by his work. Callahan considered this photograph
as the first time he broke with Adams's ideas about tone and texture:
"I was photographing weeds in snow. I looked through the camera and
I just saw the lines." Later, Callahan tilted the camera toward the
sky to eliminate all other elements of the picture. This high contrast
print further reduces the world to essential forms.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Telephone Wires, ca. 1950s
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.816
-
- Telephone Wires, ca. 1950s
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.867
-
- Telephone Wires, ca. 1950s
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.868
-
- Using a reductionist approach to complexity, Callahan
depicted criss-crossing telephone wires silhouetted against the
sky as symbols of modernity, communication and electricity, but also more
essentially as simply lines, rhythm and tension. Callahan explained:
"It's the subject matter that counts, but I'm interested in revealing
the subject in a new way to intensify it."
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Ivy Tentacles on Glass, Chicago,
ca. 1952
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Callahan painstakingly arranged this composition, influenced
by the abstract paintings he saw in New York. The background appears white
because he laid the ivy tentacles on a sheet of glass lit from behind using
a white cardboard reflector.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Eleanor, 1951
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- In this image of his wife, Eleanor, overlaying a view
of a thicket, Callahan has drawn a deep connection between the feminine
and nature. She is shown silhouetted in the window of their open-plan
Chicago apartment, a vast space that was once a ballroom. Callahan's use
of multiple exposures was certainly encouraged by the influence of Bauhaus
practitioners such as László Moholy-Nagy and Arthur Siegel,
but he had experimented with multiple exposures before moving to
Chicago.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Eleanor and Barbara, Chicago,
1953
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Much of Callahan's portraiture of Eleanor is from the
first few years of their daughter Barbara's life, when Eleanor, previously
the primary bread-winner, took an extended leave from work. Although it
resembles a snapshot, this image has an underlying complexity of lines,
patterns and planes. Callahan used a large-format, 8x10-inch camera; the
resulting negatives produce detailed images of great clarity.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Collage, Chicago, 1957
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Callahan began experimenting with collage by cutting
up magazines such as Vogue and Harper's. He
pinned printed fragments of models' heads and eyes up on the wall and then
transformed them back into a single, unified photograph.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Grasses, Wisconsin, 1959
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- The overall composition of Callahan's iconic image of
grasses, its gestural linearity, graphic contrast and shallow two-dimensional
space, parallel the formal investigations seen in abstract painting at
this time.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Light Abstraction, 1946
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.850
-
- Camera Movement on Flashlight,
1946 47
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.845
-
- This image was made the year Callahan began teaching
at the Institute of Design, Chicago, founded by Moholy-Nagy and dedicated
to design, form and experimentation-and the philosophy of the Bauhaus.
The study of light was emphasized in the curriculum. Callahan began experimenting
with light by moving his camera while photographing a flashlight in the
darkroom. The resulting abstract, linear images were akin to the calligraphic,
automatic drawings of the Surrealists. Like Siskind and Sommer, Callahan
felt an affinity for the effects of chance and spontaneity.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Aix-en-Provence, France,
1957
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Like Sommer's Arizona Landscape and Siskind's
Badlands 72, Callahan's Aix-en-Provence, France is similarly
dense, textural and "horizonless." Callahan's tangled forest
of trees, lines, shadows and branches provide no entry point for the viewer
and demands close inspection and total absorption.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Eleanor, 1953
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Callahan continually recorded his wife, Eleanor,
seeking to create new associations and meanings within the parameters of
a single subject. Here, he was experimenting with out-of-focus imagery.
Callahan printed the silhouetted forms of his wife and daughter in extreme
contrast, to emphasize their presence without referencing their individual
identities or physicality.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Providence, 1967
- Collection of the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas
City, Missouri, Gift of Hallmark Cards, Inc., 2005.27.153
-
- Providence demonstrates Callahan's
use of in-camera multiple exposures to create a layered, collagelike
image with its own internal syntax. A variation of Siskind and Sommer's
"found collages," this rare print is an example of Callahan's
reliance on chance and the unknown. He intuitively placed the looming screen
of the television over the image of the woman, working in the blind zone
of the double exposure, and thus produced a tension-laden image of urban
loneliness, isolation and voyeurism.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Eleanor, Chicago, 1949
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Eleanor, Chicago is an image
of life and death. Eleanor appears as a Venus emerging from a primordial
sea but also as a disembodied head, with closed eyes and a strangely disturbing,
surreal pall.
-
-
- Harry Callahan
- Eleanor, Indiana, 1948
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Taken at the dunes alongside Lake Michigan,
Eleanor, Indiana tells the story of its own evolution. Footsteps
in the sand record Eleanor's movements as Callahan sent her in one direction
and then another. Callahan said of this picture: Once I was photographing
my wife with a big 8x10 camera on the shores of Lake Michigan in Chicago.
She was standing there smiling, and it looked just like a snapshot. I thought,
"This is terrific. After I print it, I'll make 8x10 snapshots."
So I started doing that. That's the unexpected. I'm trying to answer the
unexpected.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Pleasures and Terrors of Levitation 25, 1957
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- This early example of the iconic series "Pleasures
and Terrors of Levitation" illustrates Siskind's use
of scale, stark contrast and bold abstraction. Simultaneously balanced
in stasis, yet disturbingly excised from context, the levitating subject
is hermetically sealed by Siskind's obliteration of all contextual information.
Free fall in a fetal position, he seems related to the widespread
interest in existentialism during the 1950s: man isolated, autonomous and
in the moment.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Chicago 10, 1948
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Chicago 10 is an example
of Siskind's interest in the "found image" and graffiti. This
central, abstracted feminine form evokes an archetypal human presence.
An urban hieroglyphic, the found image emerges from the scrawled, gestural
pattern on a weathered wall.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- North Carolina 30, 1951
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- This image is an example of Siskind's found collages
of layered imagery, perhaps related to the free-association Surrealist
games he and Sommer played together during his sojourn in Arizona. Here,
Siskind framed random language and image to insinuate meaning. The female
with three legs (captured between the words "IN" and "AND")
is in an overt sexual reference.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Badlands 72, 1970
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- On a six-day road trip to South Dakota with two of his
students, Siskind made a series of abstract landscapes, "Badlands."
The ambiguity of scale and textures of the rock parallel similar features
seen in Siskind's earlier, urban found abstractions. The tight cropping
and full-frame image create tension at the edge, giving it an other-worldly
feel as in Sommer's "horizonless" landscapes.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Homage to Franz Kline, Lima 63,
1975
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- This work belongs to an extensive, essentially painterly
photographic series made to honor Franz Kline, the pivotal Abstract Expressionist
painter who had been Siskind's close friend during his time in New York.
Throughout the series, Siskind focused closely on found abstractions
that resemble the broad black brushstrokes of Kline's gestural canvases.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Saguaros 2, 1949
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Siskind's image of a dying saguaro dates from his photographic
excursions with Sommer in Arizona. Siskind's great interest in texture
and gesture are evident here, as the cactus's failing arms stretch calligraphically
against the sky.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Jerome, Arizona, 1949
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Siskind visited Sommer in Prescott, Arizona, in 1949,
and ended up renting a cottage in the Mountain Club (where Sommer
lived) for several months; he used Sommer's darkroom. This well-known image
of a peeling wall in the nearby mining town of Jerome represents
Siskind's interest in finding incidents of abstraction within the world.
Siskind shared this preoccupation with the Abstract Expressionists,
many of whom were his friends. Siskind believed that the thing being photographed
"serves only a personal need and the requirements of the picture,"
rather than reality.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Gloucester 1H, 1944
-
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- This image of a glove lying discarded on a wharf represents
Siskind's significant shift from documentary photography to what he called
the "drama of objects." In his photographs, Siskind created
visual relationships that corresponded with his interior world. Describing
in 1945 the work he made during this time, he stated: "Essentially,
then, these photographs are psychological in characterit seems to me that
this kind of picture satisfies a needthe interior drama is the meaning
of the exterior event."
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Chicago 206, 1953
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Through abstraction and metaphor, Siskind helped detach
photography from a dependence on subject specificity. He remarked: "I
found marks which brought me very close to the people who had made these
marks-writings which had obvious meanings-uninhibited writings whose meanings
were indecipherable." Chicago 206, a "found" collage
of letters, numbers, and blocks of color, records the wall's many histories
but reveals none of its mysteries.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Chicago 42, 1952
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- "It is as though the wall was a kind of a mirror
image of a world. But the mirror image is already one step toward my picture."
Thus, Siskind claimed that a wall offered a ready-made flat plane just
waiting to be assimilated into a photograph. The paint splotches are organized
neatly into a geometric grid reminiscent of an architectural façade.
However, the haphazard drips of the paint interrupt the orderly world with
the chaos of gestural painting.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Seaweed 2, 1943
-
- Seaweed 7, 1953
-
- Seaweed 8, 1953
-
- Martha's Vineyard 9, 1947
-
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- In the early 1940s, while on vacation from his job teaching
high school in New York, Siskind spent his summers at Martha's Vineyard.
His studies of seaweed variously mimic a found letter, a loop symbolizing
infinity, a descent into chaos, a shifting Rorschach inkblot, rearranged
by the flux of sand and surf. He commented: "I was operating on a
plane of ideas. The shift was from description to idea and meaning. That
is what changed my course from documentary photography to something else."
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Martha's Vineyard 108, 1954
-
- Martha's Vineyard, 1954
-
- Martha's Vineyard IIIb, 1954
-
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Siskind made numerous studies of balancing rocks at Martha's
Vineyard, silhouetting them against a white sky suspended in a horizonless
frame. The arrangement of the rocks underscores the importance of
contiguity, each rock held in equilibrium by its relationship to another.
Siskind explained: "For the first time in my life subject matter,
as such, had ceased to be of primary importance. Instead, I found myself
involved in the relationships of these objects, so much so that these pictures
turned out to be deeply moving and personal experiences."
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- Chicago 231B, 1954
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Similar to the Abstract Expressionists' embracing the
flatness of the canvas, Siskind emphasized the flat plane of the photograph
rather than illusionistic space. Here, the photograph freezes the sense
of gesture and intention in the act of paint flung against the wall; drips
record the passage of time and reveal the traces of how the mark was made.
-
-
- Aaron Siskind
- San Luis Potosi 16, 1961
-
- Irapuato 2, 1961
-
- Collection of Barbara and Gene Polk, Prescott, Arizona
-
- Siskind visited Mexico in 1955 and again in 1972, eventually
traveling further to Peru. On his journeys, he became entranced with disintegrating
handbills pasted onto walls. He commented: "Even the way posters are
torn or the way they are laid over each other. Different shapes that are
related to the gestures of the guy who put the glue on." Each tatter
reveals fragments of letters, evoking memory and the object's history.
-
-
-
- Frederick Sommer
- Coyotes, 1945
- Collection of the Frederick and Frances Sommer Foundation,
Prescott, Arizona
-
- In this image, one of Sommer's best-known photographs,
the desiccated bodies of coyotes refer to the cycles of life and
death in nature. Hunters had left the bodies to decay in the Arizona desert.
Despite being a grotesque example of cruelty and waste, the four coyotes
appear gracefully frozen in time, as though they are on the verge of leaping
outside the frame. Sommer enjoyed the ambiguity of the subject precariously
perched between life and death.
-
-
- Frederick Sommer
- Venus, Jupiter and Mars,
1949
- Collection of the Frederick and Frances Sommer Foundation,
Prescott, Arizona
-
- Venus, Jupiter and Mars is
a prime example of Sommer's practice of arranging and photographing "found
objects." Drawing on his erudite literary knowledge and probably his
close friendship with Max Ernst, the Surrealist painter, Sommer titled
the three figures, visible amidst shreds of a found poster, after the
Roman gods. Sommer explained: "Then you might ask, is it legitimate
to arrange anything? Yes and you then have to work with the consequences
of what you have done."
-
-
- Frederick Sommer